Up until last weekend, the closest I've ever come to making a cream pie was a cheater chocolate pudding pie (pre-made pie crust + box of instant chocolate pudding + Cool Whip). The resulting pie was boring and bland, but the kids loved it. (Go figure.)
Honestly, cream pies just aren't my favorite.
I always, always reach for a fruit pie over a cream one. Plus, the thought of making a cream pie was always sort of intimidating, which is why my half-assed attempt was so, well, half-assed.
So, to venture into the world of cream pies, I figured it was best to first try a proven cream pie recipe from a cream pie expert. I picked up Lauren Chattman's Icebox Pies and gave her Raspberry and Cocoa Marscapone Cream Pie a whirl.
I followed her recipe and whipped together cocoa powder, confectioner's sugar, marscapone cheese and heavy whipping cream.
![]() |
In the background is the photo of how the recipe should turn out. (It had me at "hello" with that chocolate crust and those plump, glorious berries.) |
![]() |
I learned through trial and error to beat the filling until soft peaks form. (My first batch resembled melted chocolate ice cream.) |
Once the filling was the right consistency, I spooned it into a home made chocolate cookie crust (also in the book) that had raspberry jam smeared in the bottom. Then, I topped the whole thing with fresh raspberries and gave it a light dusting of confectioner's sugar.
![]() |
Viola! |
Thank you, Ms. Chattman. Despite being incredibly easy, this pie was elegant and sophisticated. The coulis (also in the book) was incredible. (And I can't stop saying it, "Coulis, coulis, coulis!")
Obviously, I can't use someone else's recipe for the contest, so I'm already thinking of ways to change it up. Besides, if you're not a fan of marscapone, this pie is not for you. Not wanting to risk displeasing a judge, I'm considering replacing the marscapone with cream cheese and making a mocha-flavored filling instead.
Or maybe I'll see what adding a little rum will do. (Generally speaking, I think nearly everything's better with rum.)
Still, this pie was so good, it lasted only a day and a half. I shared a few slices with the neighbors, but my husband and I managed to polish it off ourselves in record time. (Hubby even licked his plate clean.)
Oh, and if I can just have a moment here...
I swear, nothing beats the smell a fresh-baked chocolate cookie crust. Nothing.
That heavenly, chocolaty aroma was so wonderfully decadent -- so simply orgasmic, it took every ounce of my being to resist devouring it out straight out of the pan, sans filling.
In the end, I'm glad I restrained myself.
And I'm especially glad that my first foray into the world of cream pies was a smashing success.
~ ~ ~ ~
P.S. In case you're counting along, there are only 233 days left until the pie bake-off.