Judging

Dominating a community pie bake-off takes time and research.

My approach to find the perfect recipes is scientific. Each test pie is rated against a 20-point scale. The scale has five categories:

Overall appearance
Crust
Consistency/texture
Taste

A perfect pie would earn 5 points in each category, for a total score of 20.

Each Pie Shark recipe needs to earn a perfect 20.

Or better.